(Admin note: Discuss backpacks and implementations here. Please keep your feedback civil and constructive.)
- Report Post
1000 Comments
Post is closed for further comments because the limit of comments per post has been reached.
-
I think we should have backpacks, I am a very nomadic player and hardly settle in one area for long. I think a balanced way to implement backpacks to make it less OP would lend itself useful to the game.
It can only be carried on the chest-plate slot when it contains items but in inventory when empty. This will make you have to choose protection over extra storage.
Crafted with 8 leather and a chest.
Upgrade-able with 8 iron, 8 gold, 8 diamond for later game size increase.
Each respective upgrade allows a little more armor protection than the last and allows you to enchant later in game. But still offering less protection overall compared to the chest-plate of the same material.
I often end up getting a Llama or Mule to help but that isn't always useful, backpacks could make the adventurous nomadic style of play much more entertaining.
Shulker boxes are useless in this circumstance because you pretty much have to complete the game in order to be able to craft them. Backpacks would be a better early game solution.
GUYS! just stop fighting whether or not backpacks and shulker are the same because it is stupid!!!! Also I always run out of room in early game because I like to explore so it would be a good addition for people who are like me.
I've been playing Minecraft since it was released for the XBox 360 in 2011. I've played on the 360, the computer, and now I'm playing on the XBox One. One of the first items I thought that Minecraft should have is the backpack. The backpack would take one inventory slot. The player could only carry one. The backpack would add nine inventory slots. The backpack would be created by placing eight pieces of leather in a circle, as we build chests. It was a simple idea for a simpler game. I think, as this simple idea, it would still work.
What if you wore it where you had elytra, and it was crafted with a chest surrounded by leather? This would be great for early game expeditions while a shulker box requires you to beat the game.This wouldn't be too overpowered because you could only have one. Great Idea!
Shulker boxes are already there in endgame. Mid game Silk Touch pick and Enderchest are sufficient. Early game Nether portal and horse let you bring your stuff home fast enough. There is a backpack for donkeys already where you can do exactly what you are asking for: have additional space when traveling.
No need for additional slots from my side, please learn to manage your inventory a bit. My tip: carry a book-n-quill with you, and a stack lumber. When full, write your coords into the book, make a crafting table with the wood, make a double chest with the wood, put everything into the chest and move onward. Pick it up later (when you have Enderchest / Shulker box) by reading the coordinates in the book. Just don´t loose the book.
Ok, there is one backpack idea that I would approve of: In case that we make eating different kinds of foods valuable for the player instead of just having him chunk tons of steaks, he somehow would have to be able to carry those different types of food with him. In that case, a "lunchbox" would be something where he could stock different food types instead of blocking ~12 slots in his inventory.
Let us assume, food rots ...
https://feedback.minecraft.net/hc/en-us/community/posts/360017259811-make-food-able-to-rot
... whenever a new season starts (maybe 3 moon cycles) ...
https://feedback.minecraft.net/hc/en-us/community/posts/360009353652-Seasons-for-most-biomes
... and instead of healing us for a small portion, having eaten different kinds of food during a day increases our health recovery speed for that day - we would have to directly heal us with consuming healing herbs and healing potions for recovering health directly ...
https://feedback.minecraft.net/hc/en-us/community/posts/360043067271-Hunger-Goes-Down-Slower-PLEASE-
... (this would also need sand to recover, for we would need to make more health - throwing (for faster usage) - potions) ...
... this would leave is with 2 backpacks:
- a "lunchbox" to contain different kinds of food during a season, to improve our basic health regeneration rate
- a "potion box" (maybe a belt like in Diablo 2?) to bring along larger amounts of healing potions
I think bags/backpacks/quivers are certainly something that's been a long time coming. Upon equipping one in the chest slot the player should get maybe 3 more item slots above their off-hand slot (shield) to mirror the armor spaces. This would make them more balanced since they cant hold tremendous amounts and they'd need to be equipped in and armor slot to be accessed. I think this would be especially useful for quivers, giving the player 3 ammo slots. It'd also be nice if these slots allowed the stacking of potions or larger stacks of ammo items that normally go only to 16, like eggs or snowballs.
I think backpacks could work pretty well and their addition will become more and more required as minecraft keeps getting more and more different items.
In my opinion could this work two different ways:
1. Backpack is an early-game-item;
It takes one armor slot (chestplate
would make the most sense) and won't
be too cheap, nor too expensive (yes
gold, no diamonds); when you remove it
from your armor, all items inside it will
drop to the floor.2. Backpack is an end-game-item; it works
the same as the example above, but it
will retain its items once unequiped
much like a shulker box; the recipe
contains a shulker box.In both examples I see the backpack as an extention to your inventory, everything past the 27th slot will go into the backpack (so you'll have a double chest of inventory when you press E)
I think backpacks shouldn't be like a shulkerbox but in item form (like a lot of mods do), because that's too easy and OP, especially if shulker boxes aren't required to craft it.
I 100% like the idea for backpacks they should come in different colors and sizes and some should be able to give you potion effect like regeneration or conduit power or something and in order to get shulker boxes you have to go to the end and fight the ended Dragon and go to the end city I hate going exploring or mining and running out of inventory space it's so annoying when there's things you want but don't have room in your inventory for them I think that you should be able to make as many backpacks as you want
maybe something like wearable backpacks mod were its a nice looking backpack you can color along with a open and close animation as well as you can set it down on the ground and possible hold your items on death like a gravestone wen you die
I dont think Backpacks are too needed in minecraft
I know its hard to carry tons of items specially when looting in an adventure or mining in a cave but it breaks the game.
If its going to add, it must :
Be hard to craft like 2 irons 6 leathers and a chest in middle.
Give 5-15 containers
Can carry onehow about backpack holds 9 items loses durabilaty when used. to access storage you crouch with an empty hand and hit the use key or trigger to access the storage and would fit in the shield slot
to stop people from having a thousand backpacks at once you cant have backpacks in backpacks, and just wouldn't be able to pick up two at all
Ok. So here are my thoughts
1)shipper boxes a super late game and they don’t really help you if you just need that last little bit of iron.
2)I think backpacks would be great early game especially if you plan on traveling or going on large resource gathering sessions.
3) the backpack would be great for aesthetic reasons
4) the back pack shouldn’t be 2 over powered (maybe on add and extra row to your inventory space)
5)maybe add shulker boxes to upgrade the backpack and have separate tabs of inv space?Shulker boxes may work like place-able backpacks, but they are only available in late game after defeating the enderdragon. So i feel backpacks would work great for early game, but, to even it out, backpacks would have to have less slots than a shulker box.
See the Quark mod for an alternative backpack implementation, which remains balanced and less powerful than Shulker boxes. I think this is a good solution
maybe backpacks like wearable backapcks? you can put them on by shifting and breaking the backpack and they take up a armor slot (you can turn it off in config to were you can have a chestplate and a backpack but the packpack wouldent give any armor) you would also be able to place it down pick it up with all the items still in it or have it like a grave stone for wen you die all your items go in it unless its full then it just scatters everywear how much the backpack takes up could be be 18 slots smaller then the inventory but still have quite a bit of space and would be cool if you can place it down for camping since there is the campfire
Post a new comment: