Provide feedback related to crafting, combat, enchanting, and general gameplay. Do not post bugs, support issues, or lists of random ideas. Please search!

Waves

under review

These waves should be able to move you around, move items around and should only spawn in areas where its deep.

Registered User shared this idea

June 09, 2018 19:58
Report Post

84 Comments

Post a new comment:

Please sign in to leave a comment.

Sorted by oldest

2

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

September 13, 2019 21:39

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
What do you mean by waves? Will the water rise and fall? Will it just be graphical? We will be able to turn it off, right?
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

September 15, 2019 06:41

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
i dont think that would work
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

September 15, 2019 21:38

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
I love the idea of waves. Its just a little too big of an idea , If everything is square in Minecraft.

otherwise an amazing idea
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

September 24, 2019 22:31

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Yes! Minecraft should definitely add it’s too good of an idea to pass up! I hope it gets added
(Also congrats on the announced idea btw)
1

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

September 25, 2019 14:45

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Awesome Idea this is great I hope this will be added!
1

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

September 25, 2019 14:46

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Awesome Idea this is great I hope this will be added!
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

November 15, 2019 09:57

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
A tide block like the magma and soul sand block?
1

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

November 24, 2019 20:13

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
bonus maybe mojang could also add whirlpools!
1

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

March 01, 2020 06:37

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
This should only be a practical effect
4

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

March 25, 2020 05:07

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Waves would add some lively appearance! I agree with another person's response that the waves should break near the shores, not in the deep.

If anything was going to happen in the deep, it would be swells, which I think could look cool, but I really question if it would be worth the potential trouble (like driving boats through a bunch of fluctuating water blocks...).

Curling waves would be cool for sure, but I would even just be okay with a whitewash effect that pushes you around some like flowing water already does (or like how dolphins do). Something simple, visually peaceful and lively with a slighty fun motion mechanic.

Cherry on top:
In locations where a wave (whitewash) meets a block that is greater than level with the water (Z+1), it would be cool for a small splash against the side of the Z+1 block... like waves hitting a coastal rock wall.
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

March 29, 2020 08:32

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
I don't think this could work realistically or at least wouldn't ever be worth the effort for a region stuffed of unique features already.

The reason why is that deep ocean biomes can be hundreds of blocks wide and across so if you were to add moving wave blocks, the number of block updates could be in the 1000s; way too much for Minecraft to realistically run at a decent fps, this works in mods before 1.13 since it only occurs sometimes along the coast and can still be wayyyy too much for some computers.

If however if it were an entity it would have the potential to look better but again, it being essentially a mob but again, entities are even more processing power intensive and would cause problems with the mob cap too.

This leads to the only feasible solution: particle effects. The only thing that would be remotely possible to run would be 10 or so wave particle effects per chunk. This couldn't actually interact with the player but would simulate a current that changed through out the day in deep water biomes. This is already kinda bad and probably couldn't look particularly good.

That being said, why tho? It's not very necessary and I don't think that it would add to the game, even then you would have to argue the hundreds of hours spent on a feature in a place that got one of the biggest updates yet very recently was the best choice in place of a Cave or an End update.
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

April 03, 2020 00:56

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
What waves?
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

April 03, 2020 00:57

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
What waves?
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

April 03, 2020 23:20

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
I don't know about only spawning where the water is deep, but this should definetly be a thing!
1

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

April 10, 2020 14:39

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
also if this was a feature then riding a boat will be much more exiting.
1

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

April 23, 2020 04:58

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
What if it was just a nice little tide sort of thing
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

April 24, 2020 18:36

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
an add on to this surfboards
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

May 03, 2020 07:56

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Great idea! If added, there should also be a Hydroelectric generator added too!
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

May 05, 2020 18:43

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Hola
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

May 05, 2020 18:43

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Hola
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

May 11, 2020 00:16

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
They could just be made of regular water, rather than being an entity, and maybe just spawn in ocean biomes rather than where water is deep.
1

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

June 26, 2020 16:43

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Sailboats too!
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

July 01, 2020 03:10

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
This is a great idea! Another way it could work, is that there should be tsunamis sometimes.
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

July 10, 2020 22:58

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Cool idea, but would need to have only a minor effect on movement and would need to spawn near the coast, rather than far out.
1

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

July 14, 2020 14:15

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Yes! They should appear in thunderstorms and have the potential to carry loot, or a map in a bottle that would wash up on the beach and could lead to treasure!
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

July 17, 2020 17:26

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Can you please add surfboards too! Can you let the idea of banners to decorate them too.
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

July 20, 2020 16:55

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Maybe they can do this by not having the ocean be a completely flat water body? I'm not sure about large hills of water or something like that, but water current not being constant could make for some fun and difficulty in exploring oceans.
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

July 25, 2020 22:37

Edited

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Waves can delete/Crash boats
1

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

August 09, 2020 22:07

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
This would be so cool as a part of a seafaring update! I'd love to see waves implemented as entities; that way they could push you around a bit, and make voyages more immersive. Maybe you could "ride" waves on a boat to shore for a little bit of a speed boost.
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

August 23, 2020 01:49

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Maybe smaller ones could crash along shores. they could also have a sound. I can already see people just relaxing on the beach, listening to the waves.

NOTICE

84 Comments

Post a new comment: