I feel as though this has been said or variations of this has been brought up, but I would love to start with a few positives. I like the idea of the throwing disc! It's a fun new unique weapon that can have a variety of uses for it. Here is the issue. The disc having variants per item tier takes it from a unique weapon like the trident or mace into a category that feels very alien to minecraft. The spear is safe from this because it is still quite situational but is limited to certain uses. With the throwing disc, it seems like it should rather be more akin to the Trident or Mace due to its unique capabilities. I feel very strongly like the disc should instead be discovered in either a dungeon (new or otherwise) or crafted in a similar way to the Mace. Not only this, but the two unique weapons already have a somewhat "elemental" subtheming, maybe lean into it with the disc! Have it be vaguely earth themed or something similar.
Either way, I do quite love the idea and concept of a ricocheting medium-range weapon, but I feel it being easy to craft and in tiers takes away from its place as this unique item. Secondarily, I strongly feel the throwing disc should be called a Chakram instead. Thank you for the updates and previews! I'll be excited to see the changes.
2 Comments
Please sign in to leave a comment.
Post a new comment: