4

Follow

make it so you CAN'T attribute swap with the spear.....

i am not suggesting the removal of attribute swapping..... i use it in axe pvp, when elytra macing, when stun slamming in mace pvp........ we PvPers use it all over minecraft......

however the way you can attribute swap with the spear is just completely BROKEN; you can get 4 block hits (surprisingly easily..... i tested it myself, i can easily get consistent 4 block hits.... like 10 times in a row if i'm focusing really hard........ so just imagine when people ACTUALLY get good at it)

you can also easily spam the lunge effect by swapping between an empty fist (or any random item that's not a spear) to the spear...... and activating the lunge before the animation registers...... and then going back to the empty hand right after, it's supposedly tick perfect....... but it's not hard to do whatsoever...... many tricks in pvp are tick perfect..... people use that as an argument when it doesn't make any sense...... "it's hard so it might as well stay in the game".... like what...... again..... i can easily do it when i tested it..... i think it's too over-powered.....

PLEAAAAASE, just keep attribute swapping, but make it impossible to attribute swap to or from a spear....... it would make it so balanced

Registered User shared this idea

• October 26, 2025 09:29
• Report a Concern

Please sign in to leave a comment.

• 1

  Registered User commented

  Comment actions Permalink

  • January 17, 2026 17:53
  • Report a Concern
  • Comment actions Permalink

  I honestly think the spear's mechanics need to be changed entirely. They are completely unbalanced and broken. They are like an unbalanced form of the mace. The mace at least has some counters. The spear has like none.

• 1

  Registered User commented

  Comment actions Permalink

  • March 07, 2026 15:53
  • Edited
  • Report a Concern
  • Comment actions Permalink

  Sounds like someone has a very big skill issue. Just for reference, I am pretty well skilled in mace and spear pvp, namely most types of attribute swapping. You’re okay with sword stuns, density swapping, breach swapping etc, but you can’t handle lunge swapping? It’s the main core of spear mace PvP. You’re supposing that I should mace someone, and wait two working days to use the lunge so I can follow up on another attack, but using breach to 4 tap a full netherite person, and using density to get 5 extra hearts of damage is allowed?

  other than elytra spear and lunge swapping, and maybe Dtaps if you’re good (which is also possible by using a density and breach mace instead of a spear and mace) there is no use for the spear, unless you want to mention 4 block reach, which is very rarely used in pvp. 
  
  seems like you had a very frustrating fight with a spear user and want to remove the features. Don’t worry, I hated mace pvp just like this about a few months ago. You’ll grow out of it