Sign in
Skip to main content

Discuss Minecraft's user interface, menus, settings, and input methods. Share feedback on navigation, controls, accessibility, customization, and other features that affect how players interact with the game.

← UI, Input Methods and Menu Options
8
Follow

Negative/Bad Advancements

These advancements would all have a reward but would by their nature be negative or bad. Some or all of these should probably be hidden advancements.

A good example of what I mean here is the Serious Dedication advancement (get a netherite hoe). Serious Dedication does give you 100 xp but you are essentially wasting a netherite ingot to get that hoe.

A few more examples for negative advancements would be:

Brutal Greeting: Be slain by a piglin brute. (This would be child of Those Were The Days and grant 50 xp in orbs at the place you died).

Sky's Not The Only Limit...: Die while using Elytra (by kinetic energy, firework stars from boosting, or falling.) (This would be a child of Sky's The Limit and grant 100 xp in orbs at the place you died).

Bane Of The Village: Fail to defend a village from raiders. (This would be a child of Voluntary Exile and would grant 100 xp).

REALLY Hot Stuff: Try to swim in lava (but not necessarily die from it.) (This would be a child of Hot Stuff and grant 50 xp).

Avatar
Registered User shared this idea

2 Comments

Post a new comment:

Please sign in to leave a comment.

Date Votes
Sorted by oldest
  • 0
    Registered User commented
    Comment actions Permalink

    Nice idea but there are some occasions where some people would want to get all the achievements in a hardcore world, so having to die for an achievement is abit too much

  • 0
    Registered User commented
    Comment actions Permalink

    Good point. Maybe it could be a total amount of damage at once. Taken down to two hearts would probably be a good line. At that point it's dangerous but, if you are careful, you can still get there without to big a risk.