2

Follow

experimental villager changes

im not a fan of the new villager changes. ill try to word it out without being like "new things scary change it back". first, i want to mention that the enchantment table is simply unreliable and exp expensive. i see villagers as the post early game way to get enchants. now, the biome specific trades: i really do not want to move villagers across hundreds of blocks just to get a different enchantment. moving villagers is already tedious. i think there should be a range of enchants a villager can have depending on the villager being a master, journeyman, like you did with the more important trades, instead of the biome. first with that, if for whatever reason someone wants efficiency 1 or 2, they would have to use the unreliable way using the enchantment table. im okay with not being able to get the highest level enchants, but the "too expensive" anvil feature should be removed. for some enchants to be unavailable, like trident and fishing rod enchants, to me tridents and fishing were already not used, now with the enchants being unreliable to get (enchantment table), they are not even a option anymore. i like stocking up on enchanted books as well, so those enchants become even harder to get. idea i just got: for the enchantment table, chiselled bookshelves could be used, and you get higher chances to get a enchant depending on how many of them are in the nearby chiselled bookshelves. also maybe reduce xp costs (out of characters for this feedback :/)

Registered User shared this idea

• August 03, 2023 09:40
• Report a Concern

Please sign in to leave a comment.

• 0

  Registered User commented

  Comment actions Permalink

  • February 09, 2024 16:35
  • Report a Concern
  • Comment actions Permalink

  I think the main problem I have with this update is that it alienates new or casual players. It is suddenly barely worth it to do villagers again and I do think there needs to be some changes to how villagers work they were already tedious and frustrating to set up. It takes a solid eight plus house to set up a villager breeding set up and a whole trading hall. The average person can probably do that in a week but that is a whole week of game play already. This new update changes it so armorers are not worth it and it will take so many hours to set up a system to work. This new system does not account for poor world generation. If you do not have a swamp for 5000 blocks (like exists in a realm I play with my friends) you essentially cannot access mending unless you have the time to transport a villager 5000 blocks and then back. I love minecraft I really do but I do not like this fix at all. It does not feel realistic for most of minecraft's demographic. A suggestion I saw and that I liked was making the plains villager a jack of all trades, master of none where they offer all trades but at a low level, ie protection 2 instead of 3 and make it so they are unable to get to that high level. They are still able to offer mending but they could change the way probability to make it harder to get mending specifically if that is what they are worried about.