3

Bring Back Blocking (But Better)

Rather than having a shield be the sole means of defense against sustaining incoming attacks for an unarmored player, the sword blocking mechanic should be returned to the game with different functionality and requirements. Blocking with a sword should:

• only take place when no shield is present in the offhand
• only take effect when timed correctly (within 2-3 ticks of an incoming attack, maybe based on difficulty)
• only affect attacks within a small (20-30°) cone, rather than the full 180° of a shield
• only affect physical, non-projectile attacks, and only up to a certain level of damage which increases with the "strength" potion effect
• possibly be able to block some projectiles, but with a much smaller targeting area

The rationale behind this idea is mostly to offer a less extreme alternative to using a shield, in order to make the offhand slot more useful in combat for items like food, fishing rods, potions, etc.

It would also serve as an incentive to use a sword in particular, as opposed to a trident or axe; this would make balancing axes as weapons easier, as they would no longer be universally better. This change could open up more opportunities for unique enchantments and other mechanics as well, for example an enchantment that increases the targeting area of blocking but is incompatible with sharpness, or an enchantment that helps in bypassing opponents' blocks.

As it stands, minecraft's combat system is little more than a game of chicken with axes and shields.

Registered User shared this idea

• September 06, 2022 01:46
• Report a Concern

Please sign in to leave a comment.

• 1

  Registered User commented

  Comment actions Permalink

  • September 06, 2022 01:53
  • Edited
  • Report a Concern
  • Comment actions Permalink

  I would like to note that this is not meant to replace a shield. It should be sufficiently underpowered that using a shield is objectively better in its own right, but strong enough that the opportunities it opens up make up for it.

  I also don't think you should be able to block arrows with it, even if you can block larger projectiles like eggs and snowballs; arrows are already countered by shields, and forcing bow/crossbow users to play around two hard counters would be unfair.