When you are making your redstone suggestions, please note that Java and Bedrock will not have the exact same the same redstone systems - this would require redoing redstone system completely on one platform or the other. The two systems are functionally different and are going to stay that way. Please be sure to tag your suggestions with (Java) or (Bedrock).

Redstone on Walls/Wall placement (was: Placement)

under review

I think you should Be able to place redstone on walls going up because it would make it a lot easier to use. And in real life, wires dont only go on floors, they go up walls.

Registered User shared this idea

June 08, 2018 14:41
Edited
Report Post

182 Comments

Post a new comment:

Please sign in to leave a comment.

Sorted by oldest

43

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

June 08, 2018 16:16

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
But redstone dust (non-solid) is not a wire (solid). I had made a suggestion that solves this problem along with others: https://feedback.minecraft.net/hc/en-us/community/posts/360009229472-Redstone-parity-Solving-quasi-connectivity-by-redstone-dust-block-
27

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

June 09, 2018 01:19

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
@WildStrongGamer: As an amateur redstoner I totally agree we need a simpler way to allow redstone signals to go vertically up & down, without tall redstone dust towers/steps

@ SpecialisToL: I too also came up with an idea some time ago for a craftable block(rod) to allow redstone signals to travel up/down....The 'Redstone rod'/'Redstone Rod Repeater'... which I posted on the minecraft forums

https://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-java-edition/suggestions/2823301-new-block-suggestion-redstone-rod-send-signals
15

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

June 09, 2018 02:01

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
To be honest, I don't understand the problem here. The problem is so easy to solve with existing mechanics. In 2xNx1 space (place dust on top slabs alternating on each side for up only, use glass instead for bi-directional). What is it that bothers people so much that it has to be done in 1xNx1 space? There are 3 separate suggestions for this "problem", 4 if you include mine which has an entirely different purpose, and this one has one of the highest number of votes in redstone section. I think the real issue may be lack of explanation for how redstone works, maybe a dedicated part in the help section explaining the basics.
16

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

July 16, 2018 09:32

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
no, only make it so it goes up slime blocks
7

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

July 29, 2018 19:59

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Redstone vines?
16

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

September 20, 2018 20:33

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
For Bedrock edition also.
2

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

September 21, 2018 02:31

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
This obsolete redstone system has been around for years and never has changed and is not now that they will change it, even if it is not consistent with reality
19

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

September 23, 2018 13:34

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
There used to be a mod on java edition that used slime ball and redstone dust to make red stone paste and that could be run up walls not only dust but could also use slime on repeaters and comparators it let you run them up walls or on ceilings
21

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

October 09, 2018 12:32

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Maybe you could craft a sort of sticky redstone by combining redstone dust and a slime ball, so it sticks to the block.
3

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

October 13, 2018 00:20

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
yes🙂
8

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

October 17, 2018 21:15

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Redstone should be changed into a wire and be called redstone wire/wires.
5

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

November 01, 2018 11:16

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
True, but Minecraft should add new redstone components such as wires and block spinners and they should make a sticky block that sticks to redtone components only.. because they won't stick to the blocks around elevators
1

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

November 01, 2018 11:16

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
True, but Minecraft should add new redstone components such as wires and block spinners and they should make a sticky block that sticks to redtone components only.. because they won't stick to the blocks around elevators
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

November 04, 2018 05:28

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
红石＋粘液球
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

November 25, 2018 01:05

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Why not roofs? Wires rarely go on roofs but they do.
1

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

December 22, 2018 06:56

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
It would be cool!
4

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

January 01, 2019 18:41

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
You can place it on walls but wouldn't it be cool to place it under a block
4

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

January 13, 2019 18:08

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
I agree but you should have to add 1 slime to 8 redstone dust and call it redstone paste. also if we could get sticky components even if it only works on top and bottom of blocks that'd be great.
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

January 20, 2019 21:22

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Yea sticky red stone even if it cost more to place on walls by requiring more resources would be very interesting to see what could be made. Several mods have implemented this via wire or sticky redstone.
9

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

January 20, 2019 23:59

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
There are a couple options here:
1. Redstone Paste - Created by mixing redstone and slime balls. Looks the same as normal redstone but with a green hue and can be placed on walls ceilings.

2. Redstone Wire - Recipe here could be similar or a bit more complex, maybe adding a new ore like copper (copper + redstone + slime balls = redstone wire). Same functionality described above, but the looks would be more like an actual wire with a 2x2 3d model perhaps to provide some shape. Still would have to be placed on a block to work.

3. Redstone Pipe - This is probably the most advanced implementation of this idea. It would essentially function as its own block but look like a pipe. This way you could route redstone signals in any direction (e.g. up and down now) in a single vertical 1x1 column without using other blocks as support. The use of copper or another sturdy material here would also make a lot of sense.
2

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

January 21, 2019 05:36

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Dust is dust after all. What we need is a redstone wire, created by somehow combining iron ingots and redstone dust.
5

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

January 21, 2019 07:05

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
How about sticky redstone? Crafted with a slimeball giving it the ability to be placed up the sides of blocks, up walls and possibly ceilings if possible. If redstone was able to be placed on top and bottom, left and right of a block you would have a full-duplex cable with 2 lines of output and 2 of input around one block.
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

January 22, 2019 03:10

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
I dont know how this will help, but I mean i guess
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

January 27, 2019 09:48

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
IIRC you can just use glowstone for vertical redstone.
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

January 31, 2019 04:19

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
This would be far too powerful in my opinion. Unless it was only able to go up to 2 or 3 blocks up and took 1 power per vertical block, or took 2 power per vertical block, I couldn't see this being very balanced.
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

January 31, 2019 20:35

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
Ink sack + red stone = cable
1

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

February 06, 2019 02:19

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
I would love to see this in game.
1

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

February 07, 2019 08:18

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
I think it's possible to make Redstone hard by adding clay. Hard Redstone can be placed under walls without being destroyed by water flow.
1

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

February 12, 2019 21:33

Edited

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
You could maybe add a new type of redstone, like combining 8 redstone in a square in a crafting table with a slimeball in the middle which would give you 8 sticky redstone, kind of like a paste rather than a dust!
2

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

February 26, 2019 21:15

Report Comment

Comment actions Permalink
The easiest solution here is to craft redstone wire using redstone dust and iron that could go vertical. I think the new furnace block has 2 slots and that would be a fine way both to use the block and cook up some redstone wire.

NOTICE

182 Comments

Post a new comment: