X

NOTICE

Are you sure you want to report this?

If you want to propose a change to an existing structure (like villages), or add something brand new in a current dimension or biome, this is the place.

1154

Naturally generated structures need redesign

under review

55 Comments

Post a new comment:

Please sign in to leave a comment.

  • 0
    Comment actions Permalink

    We need that oooh ahhh felling bois

  • 1
    Comment actions Permalink

    Perhaps they could keep the old designs well adding new ones. Also improving gameplay and respawn would be helpful. 

  • 1
    StarMonkey08 commented
    Comment actions Permalink

    I'm at least glad that they did a village redesign because the regular villages had become... well, bland. I'm sure Minecraft will look better with some extra structure redesign, however. I mean, how many of you get annoyed while trying to find treasure in the Nether fortresses and getting lost? With a simple redesign, maybe things won't be so... irritating.

    Also, the dungeons really need to be more difficult to get in to.

  • 1
    Comment actions Permalink

    I agree naturally generated structures need a huge update. 

    Logdotzip made a video about it and I think its great.

    SystemZee also made a video about structures that should be added and I agree. 

     

  • 2
    Comment actions Permalink

    This would be great. Villages have already had a redesign, but everything else I totally agree with. Changes wouldn't have to be drastic, but small details could make them look nicer. Except Witch houses. A major redesign is needed there.

  • 2
    Comment actions Permalink

    I do think the stronghold should get a new layout with new rooms. I also find desert temples to be boring, I would like to see more traps and possibly have them be semi-random generates traps.

  • 1
    Comment actions Permalink

    It would be neat if there were a rare Nether Fortress variant, that used red, Nether brick

  • 0
    Comment actions Permalink

    Mojang, Please Make a shattered savannah village which has houses made of stripped and normal acacia logs, Acacia trap doors, Smooth stone slabs, With floating islands with houses on them. They Also have pastures with 3 mules in them renamed Village Stock Movers. These mules will not be rideable and you cannot access their chests, but in one of the surrounding houses there is a farmer selling a lead renamed Village Stock Movers Pass Costing 15 emeralds which will give you access the horse and its chest, and it will be fast. I hope you liked my suggestion!😃

  • 0
    jtappin commented
    Comment actions Permalink

    The structures are meant to make you think "I could do better" so you go in to modify, or build your own. Otherwise the game plays itself and you potentially get really frustrated when all you can build is a dirt box... 

  • 4
    Kevin Stu commented
    Comment actions Permalink

    I agree the nether fortresses and such are bland they certainly suffer from only using the blocks from when they where first added.

  • 2
    Hyromius commented
    Comment actions Permalink

    To put it simply:

    Players want to be surprised.

    The best way to provide surprises is variety.

    Said variety would also add interest and doesn't require the structures be breathtaking,

    all it requires is a few more prefabs being cycled between.

  • 4
    CraftOnABox commented
    Comment actions Permalink

    I think we should do something like this:

    Example Desert Temple:

    - Classic Desert Temple [A]
    - Variant of Classic Desert Temple [B]
    - Variant of Classic Desert Temple [C]
    - Structure Block Desert Temple 1
    - Structure Block Desert Temple 2
    - Structure Block Desert Temple 3
    - Structure Block Desert Temple 4
    - Large Structure Block Desert Temple 1 (Dynamic generation on traps and tunnels and whats inside or in side rooms)
    - Large Structure Block Desert Temple 2 (Dynamic generation on traps and tunnels and whats inside or in side rooms)


    They should make the classic desert temple we see today "Rarest" to find and the variants of it "semi rare"
    and the structure variants to be the main ones and the large structure variants to be less common than the structure ones but more than classic variants etc.

    This would add flavour to the deserts and every temple would be unique enough it would be hard to notice if its the same.

  • 2
    Comment actions Permalink

    -Nether Fortresses: Have no texture too them and appear quite bland, should include more color and variety of rooms and traps

    -Ocean Monuments: Disappointed these weren't updated in the update aquatic, should now include the new waterlogged slabs and stairs of their corresponding prismarine. Also maybe make the structure odd numbers so their less strange gaps and crevices between the rooms and that easy round about section of the monument to make it more challenging.

    -Mineshafts can do with some aesthetic changes as well as new rooms or adding TNT in random areas?

    -Desert Temples: Have Husks spawn and guard the temple like the pillager outposts! including more aesthetically pleasing details and use the new sand blocks would be perfect for this. Make the second floor useful or at least a part of the lore somehow. Maybe by making the room appear more crypt like but keep the structures design mainly

    -Jungle Temples. Same scenario as the Desert Temple can do with some second floor puzzle or trap and maybe include some new blocks to add to the lore and atmoshere.

    -Dungeons: Too easy to defeat and not a lot of adventure in them. Maybe by making multiple types of dungeons designed to fit the type of spawner it has. Adding details like high ceiling and cobwebs for spider spawners or small side rooms where skeletons can shoot you from add difficulty but makes finding them more fun. They should contain 3 parts to it: a trapped corridor, the spawner room, and the treasure room to make it seem more like something to find and go through!

  • 0
    Comment actions Permalink

    Mojang should update the nether fortress in the nether update to look like Grian's  transformation from one of his videos. 

     

  • 2
    Comment actions Permalink

    Jungle Temples are terrible! We need some re-designs.

  • 0
    Goog Gooy commented
    Comment actions Permalink

    the neather fortress would be able to use the new block in the nether update

  • 1
    INEDEBEKFEST commented
    Comment actions Permalink

    Maybe they could have expert builders make 5 or 6 designs for each structure then have them randomized for structures with a set look like desert temples. For ones where the structure itself is generated by a random procedure, they should do the same thing, but separate it into segments, so each segment will have 5-6 randomly generated designs, and the segments combine to create the whole structure.

  • 1
    Tripwire19 commented
    Comment actions Permalink

    I fully agree we should change the structures and their redstone mechanics as long as we keep it as Vannila Minecraft as possible and the block pallate is as similar as possible to the original design. Maybe Mojang should hold a contest for recreating ingame structures and the winner's design would get put in the game.

  • 2
    Comment actions Permalink

    When it comes to desert pyramids and jungle temple, they are such a good opportunity for a maze made of procedurally generated rooms with enemies, parkour, traps, puzzles, and possibly a boss similarly to Ocean Monument.

    My biggest complaint with current version of those structures is that:

    1. There is very little content - simple TNT trap that nobody will fall into after 1st time and 4 chests/simple lever puzzle that nobody will bother with since it's easier to just break the wall and dispenser almost incapable of killing anyone even it they fall into it.

    2. Once you have seen them once, you have seen all others.

  • 1
    Ryan Fong commented
    Comment actions Permalink

    Maybe dungeons could be bigger/nicer? Whenever I come across a dungeon, it's just the normal loot(rotten flesh, horse armour, maybe once in a while a music disc). It could have some traps or tripwires like in jungle temples, or maybe explode like the desert temples.

     

  • 1
    lvl 7 Jhin commented
    Comment actions Permalink

    As a player since the Redstone Update, I think the structures were really nice but over the years with the release of new blocks and the Nether Update coming out and seeing Piglin Bastions, I think the existing structures could use a total overhaul. However, if this feedback does come into fruition, I think that NEW BOSES in these existing structures would kill two birds with one stone with another problem which is the lack of Boss battles that are in the game. 

  • 2
    NutelGame commented
    Comment actions Permalink

    I just think that structures need more details, Minecraft has evolved a lot from many versions and has therefore acquired many new blocks over time and therefore allow to rejuvenate already existing structures in Minecraft.

    The build itself has also evolved a lot so it would be entirely possible to improve the structures !

  • 1
    devereaux98 commented
    Comment actions Permalink

    Fully agreed.  Just look at fanmade "redesigns" of nether fortresses and jungle temples.  They don't break the aesthetic of the game and feel much more awesome.

  • 1
    Mory TheBlobs commented
    Comment actions Permalink

    The structures could definitely use a rework, but especially the woodland mansion that you travel over ten thousand blocks to find.

    I explored a few woodland mansions in creative (using the /locate and /tp commands). It seemed the majority of the rooms would be useless in survival. For example, why would travel so far and find wool statues of a chickens and cats? Or other rooms that I could easily build with resources I already have? Even the secret rooms wit diamond blocks could be recreated with a bit of caving or branch mining. The structure needs better loot: Make chests spawn more frequently and more likely to contain enchanted golden apples. 

  • 1
    Comment actions Permalink

    The structure I most want updated is the Stronghold. It's one of the three most important structures in Minecraft and it's been around for years. But if you compare it to something like the Mansion or the 1.14 villages, it looks bland and repetitive. New rooms with things like armor stands, maps in item frames, beds, spawners, large empty chest rooms...what about an unlit Nether portal frame somewhere near the End Portal? What about new libraries that use lecterns? Please? Would love a Stronghold that's vanilla but beautiful at the same time.